Maths-
General
Easy

Question

What is the error in the student’s reasoning below ? Describe how to correct the statement ?

hintHint:

When the difference between 2 consecutive output values (y values) for a given constant change in the input values (x values) is constant. i.e. y(n)- y(n-1) is constant for any value of n, the function is known as a linear function.

The correct answer is: The error in students reasoning given is that he/she did not consider the rate of change in x variables and the correct statement would be- "The data can not be modelled with a linear function because the x variables are not at a constant interval."


    Step-by-step solution:-
    From the above definition, it is clear that for a function to be classified as a linear function, the rate of change in its y variables has to be constant for a given constant change in its x variables.
    From the given table, we can observe that-

    x1 = -3, y1 = -8;
    x2 = -1, y2 = -2;
    x3 = 0, y3 = 4;
    x4 = 1, y4 = 10 and
    x5 = 3, y5 = 16
    a). Difference between 2 consecutive x values-
                                                                                    dx1 = x2 - x1 = -1 - (-3) = -1 + 3 = 2
                                                                                     dx2 = x3 - x2 = 0 - (-1) = 0 + 1 = 1
                                                                                            dx3 = x4 - x3 = 1 - 0 = 1
                                                                                            dx4 = x5 - x4 = 3 - 1 = 2
    b). Difference between 2 consecutive y values-
                                                                                    dy1 = y2 - y1 = -2 - (-8) = -2 + 8 = 6
                                                                                     dy2 = y3 - y2 = 4 - (-2) = 4 + 2 = 6
                                                                                            dy3 = y4 - y3 = 10 - 4 = 6
                                                                                           dy4 = y5 - y4 = 16 - 10 = 6
    We can observe that although the rate of change in y variable seems to be constant @ 6, rate of change in x variables is not constant. i.e. some readings in x variable are missing that leads to a erroneous conclusion that first difference is constant.
    Hence, The error in students reasoning given is that he/she did not consider the rate of change in x variables.
    Also, the correct statement would be-
    "The data can not be modelled with a linear function because the x variables are not at a constant interval."
    Final Answer:-
    ∴ The error in students reasoning given is that he/she did not consider the rate of change in x variables and the correct statement would be- "The data can not be modelled with a linear function because the x variables are not at a constant interval."

    Related Questions to study

    General
    Maths-

    Compare the functions f(x)= 3X+2 , g(x)= 2x2+3 and h(x)= 2x . Show that as x increases , h(x) will eventually exceed f(x) and g(x).

    Compare the functions f(x)= 3X+2 , g(x)= 2x2+3 and h(x)= 2x . Show that as x increases , h(x) will eventually exceed f(x) and g(x).

    Maths-General
    General
    Maths-

    Solve the radical equation square root of 15 minus x end root minus square root of 6 x end root equals negative 3

    Solve the radical equation square root of 15 minus x end root minus square root of 6 x end root equals negative 3

    Maths-General
    General
    Maths-

    Calculate the second difference for data in the table. Use a graphing calculator to find the quadratic regression for each data set. Make a conjecture about the relationship between the a values in the quadratic models and the second difference of the data.

    Calculate the second difference for data in the table. Use a graphing calculator to find the quadratic regression for each data set. Make a conjecture about the relationship between the a values in the quadratic models and the second difference of the data.

    Maths-General
    parallel
    General
    Maths-

    Solve the radical equationsquare root of 6 x minus 20 end root minus x equals negative 6. Check for extraneous solutions

    Solve the radical equationsquare root of 6 x minus 20 end root minus x equals negative 6. Check for extraneous solutions

    Maths-General
    General
    Maths-

    Use the functions shown :
    a. Evaluate each function for x=6 , x=8 and x=12
    b. When will function h exceed function f and function g ?

    Use the functions shown :
    a. Evaluate each function for x=6 , x=8 and x=12
    b. When will function h exceed function f and function g ?

    Maths-General
    General
    Maths-

    The graph shows population models for three cities , based on data over a five year period. If the populations continue to increase in the same ways , when will the population of city C exceed the populations of the other two cities ?

    The graph shows population models for three cities , based on data over a five year period. If the populations continue to increase in the same ways , when will the population of city C exceed the populations of the other two cities ?

    Maths-General
    parallel
    General
    Maths-

    Calculate the second difference for data in the table. Use a graphing calculator to find the quadratic regression for each data set. Make a conjecture about the relationship between the a values in the quadratic models and the second difference of the data.

    Calculate the second difference for data in the table. Use a graphing calculator to find the quadratic regression for each data set. Make a conjecture about the relationship between the a values in the quadratic models and the second difference of the data.

    Maths-General
    General
    Maths-

    Carmen is considering two plans to pay off a $10,000 loan . The table show the amount remaining on the loan after x years . Which plan should carmen use to pay off the loan as soon as possible ? Justify your answer using a function model ?